Skip to main content

Click Here >>>For More 'Post Racial Society' Posts

Show more

Jurors begin deliberating in re-trial of Border Patrol agent in Nogales teen's killing

Jurors begin deliberating in re-trial of Border Patrol agent in Nogales teen's killing
Whether Border Patrol agent Lonnie Swartz shot and killed 16-year-old Jose Antonio Elena Rodríguez because he was fed up, or to protect himself and fellow officers from rock throwers, is what a Tucson jury will have to decide.

Attorneys on both sides made their closing arguments to jurors Friday in Swartz's federal trial on a voluntary manslaughter charge.

An earlier federal jury in Tucson acquitted Swartz of second-degree murder in Elena Rodríguez's 2012 death, but couldn't agree on lesser charges. The prosecution decided to retry the case. Swartz is the first Border Patrol agent to be tried in a cross-border shooting.

"Unreasonable and unnecessary. Unreasonable and unnecessary," that's what the shooting was, Assistant U.S. District Attorney Mary Sue Feldmeier told jurors.

When Swartz fired through the border fence at Nogales, down into Mexico 16 times, hitting Elena Rodríguez 10 times in the back and head, it wasn't about defending human life, she said, it was about not giving in.

"There's no justification for what happened that night," Feldmeier said, saying use of deadly force should be a last resort.

From the Mexican side, there is a cliff about 14 feet tall with the bollard-style fence extending another 22 feet. To clear the fence with a rock, a person would have had to throw it at least 36 feet into the air, higher than a three-story building. Or, they would have to get the rocks through the 4-inch gaps between the bollards.

But the defense countered Swartz acted in self- defense in a dangerous area. "The government tried to downplay how dangerous it is to be a Border Patrol agent down by the border," defense attorney Sean Chapman told the jury. "They must be living in an alternate universe that they want you to join them. Don't do it. You were there, you know what it's like."

They jury visited the shooting site during the trial.

On Oct. 10, 2012, the night Swartz killed Elena Rodríguez, agents and local police officers responded to reports of a couple of drug smugglers jumping the fence, dropping off marijuana backpacks and running back south.

Swartz was among three Border Patrol agents who responded. Shortly after he and the others arrived, a group of people started to throw rocks at the officers so the two smugglers stranded on top of the fence could flee.

Almost immediately after, Border Patrol surveillance video shows Swartz leaving cover behind an SUV and approaching the fence with his weapon drawn. He is seen putting his hands through the four-inch gaps and shooting three times. He then moves right for another eight seconds, puts his gun through the slats and fires 10 more times; then reloads and shoots three more shots.

While law enforcement officers are asked to make split-second decisions in rapidly evolving and tense circumstances, this was not a split-second decision, Feldmeier said. "He didn't stop and assess the situation as he is trained," she said. "It was a thoughtful and deliberate sequence of events over 34 seconds."

None of the other agents or police officers shot across the border, she pointed out. Swartz exaggerated the threat, she said, to justify his actions.

Swartz said he heard a "ping" from a rock heating the fence, heard another agent say he had been hit (who testified he didn't remember saying it), and a thud of a rock hitting a police officer's canine before he responded.

And that's what Chapman told the jury they should consider when making their decision: what did Swartz perceive that night? "You have to put yourselves in his shoes."

He asked them to use a wrist watch while they deliberate and to have everyone be quiet for 30 seconds to get a feel for how long the shooting was. "This thing happened in half a minute."

Swartz didn't have to hide or seek cover, Chapman said. "He is allowed to use his experience and say 'this is a scary, deadly force situation'."

"Agents are told from first day that rocks are deadly weapons, potentially," he said. "We may not like that, but that's how they are trained."

Between 2010 and 2014 agents were rocked 1,713 times, he told the jury. Out of those they responded with deadly force 43 times, which resulted in 10 deaths.

Chapman used that number to show the frequency of the rockings. But Feldmeier divided the number of rockings per year to come up with .02 rockings per agent, if divided by 20,000 agents, or .04 rockings if divided by 10,000 agents.

Within Swartz's first year, she said, he was involved in seven rocking incidents to which he largely responded with the use of less-lethal force, such as pepper ball launchers.

This, she said, paints a picture of an agent looking for trouble akin to a fighter who as soon as he hears the bells, comes out punching. She said he acted like someone who had trained himself to immediately react to rockings by using some kind of force.

To Chapman though, the fact that he always used a less-lethal weapon before showed an agent who would have avoided deadly force that night if he had the option. But because he had been working at the nearby port of entry that night, he didn't have access to a less-lethal weapon.

Facts such as whether Elena Rodriguez died from the first shot or was alive when Swartz switched positions and continued to fire have been central to the case.

Chapman argued that Elena Rodríguez was killed within the first 10 seconds after Swartz started to shoot.

Full Article: https://www.google.com/amp/s/tucson.com/news/local/jurors-begin-deliberating-in-re-trial-of-border-patrol-agent/article_9c083fa4-1373-59e3-9293-4e75ca4c19fc.amp.html

Source: tucson.com

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Brian (Waterhead Bo) Bennett

Brian (Waterhead Bo) Bennett So who was the biggest black kingpin of all time? Just how do you measure that? Money, volume of dope, power, cultural impact? Perhaps it was Frank Matthews… you can learn more about him in my documentary “The Frank Matthews Story” link. But in terms of documented transactions that we know about for sure, who was convicted in court: One man stands alone. Brian “Waterhead Bo” Bennett. Bennett and his Colombian Partner, Mario Villabona, were eventually convicted of moving nearly l5 thousand kilos that they talked about on certain wiretaps between December of 1987 and November of 1988. Some of the loads were as large as 1000 kilos and cheaper than $9,000 dollars each wholesale. That’s 1500 keys a month for nearly a year. And that’s just on the wiretapped phones. Who knows how much he really sold in total. Claims are made about this one and that one selling more, but 15,000 keys sold for sure is the most we know about for any black dealer. Waterhead B

49ers cheerleader kneels again during anthem before 'Monday Night Football'

49ers cheerleader kneels again during anthem before 'Monday Night Football' On Nov. 1, a San Francisco 49ers cheerleader  took a knee during the national anthem ahead of the team’s Thursday night matchup with the Oakland Raiders. She was later  identified as Kayla Morris  of Antioch, California,  a second-year member  of the 49ers’ Gold Rush cheer squad. Morris declined to discuss protest Both Morris and the 49ers  declined media requests  to discuss her kneeling after the Thursday night game, and some wondered if the act of protest would cost Morris her spot on the team. It did not. On Monday, the 49ers had a second consecutive prime time matchup on “Monday Night Football”,  a loss to the New York Giants . Morris back on the field, kneels again Morris was on the field with her Gold Rush teammates prior to the game. For the second straight game, she took a knee during the national anthem. While fans in the stands noticed her kneeling the first time,

Colin Kaepernick’s Jersey Is Among The NFL’s Top Sellers

Colin Kaepernick’s Jersey Is Among The NFL’s Top Sellers Even though colin has been out of the league for years, his #7 san fran Jersey is still among the most sold amoung nfl players. Colin Kaepernick is still dealing with being blackballed by NFL owners and general managers, but at least he continues to get love from some from fans. 20 free agent quarterbacks have been signed ahead of him during the offseason, and even the blind can see that it’s a direct result of the stance he took when he refused to stand during the national anthem to protest against police brutality and systemic racism in America. The quarterback who threw for 2,241 yards and 16 touchdowns last year while starting 12 games has only been able to secure one workout with the Seattle Seahawks, despite being a few seasons removed from starting in the Super Bowl. But his fans are showing their support. Among last months best-selling jerseys released by the NFL Shop, Kaepernick ranked 17th ahead of quarterbac

Adam Silver Thinks A Rule Will Make Players Stand For The Anthem

Adam Silver Thinks A Rule Will Make Players Stand For The Anthem The rise of player protests against racial injustice has presented a problem for money-driven league commissioners and owners. An age of enlightenment, social activism and unified awareness concerning police brutality and racial inequality is flourishing in pro sports and motivating Black athletes to finally understand the magnitude of their power and use it to challenge the outdated and oppressive status quo and form of financial and psychological control that has been prevalent in pro sports.   Since Colin Kaepernick took a knee and even before that with the Black Live Matter Movement and players expressing their social and political views on traditional sports platforms such as The ESPYs, the game has changed and league execs and owners are scrambling to find a way to regain control of the minds and bodies of their players. Full Article: https://theshadowleague.com/nba-commissioner-adam-silver-s-belief-that-a-

Whites have rights': billboard

A Pennsylvania billboard has sparked an outcry and accusations of racism — but the man who put it up insists that he’s simply trying to strike up a “conversation” about race. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/whites... #whytheracecardisplayed

The Three Civil Rights–Era Leaders Who Warned of Computers and Racism

More than 50 years later, will the U.S.—and Silicon Valley—hear their message?

Kenyans had the highest number of casualties and are not named. Ethiopians are not named. Egyptians are the only Africans named.

Kenyans had the highest number of casualties and are not named. Ethiopians are not named. Egyptians are the only Africans named.  'No survivors' on crashed Boeing 737 The Associated Press Verified account: Kenyans had the highest number of casualties and are not named. Ethiopians are not named. Egyptians are the only Africans named. #whytheracecardisplayed https://twitter.com/AP/status/1104720232449478661

LeBron James Rocks Colin Kaepernick Nike T-Shirt to Lakers Preseason Game

LeBron James Rocks Colin Kaepernick Nike T-Shirt to Lakers Preseason Game LeBron James was wearing some exclusive Nike gear on his way to the Lakers' preseason game against the Kings on Thursday as he sported a 'Kaepernick' t-shirt to Staples Center. James has previously voiced his support for Colin Kaepernick  both as an NFL quarterback  and as the  face of the 30th anniversary of Nike's "Just Do It." campaign . After the apparel brand announced in September  Kaepernick would be used in advertisements  going forward, James  said  he stood for "anybody who believes in change" and added, "I stand with Nike all day, every day." LeBron James has long supported Colin Kaepernick and the movement the former NFL quarterback started by taking a knee in 2016. Now, this shouldn’t come as a huge surprise to anyone. James has  been more outspoken about social issues in recent years . He’s discussed matters like immigration, police brutality, women

Montana Malik Baronette

Montana Malik Baronette This 21-year old has been called the “Number one trigger-puller” by Baltimore city police and was only recently arrested and charged with a 2014 murder. However, police suspect that he is linked to hundreds of violent crimes and more than a dozen homicides as an alleged member of the notorious Baltimore street gang the “Black Guerilla Family”. Nothing makes a killer more infamous than a memorable nickname, and you’d be hard-pressed to find a more memorable name than “Number One Trigger Puller”.  Baronette is currently awaiting trial on the West Baltimore murder of 23-year-old Alfonso Williams. Patreon.com/theiconiumfoundation

Leaked Jenna Chat Logs Expose Twitch Streamer’s Shocking Racist, Homophobic, & Sexist Slurs

Twitch streamer Jenna is once again in hot water after Discord logs leaked, revealing the shocking use of racist, homophobic, and sexist slurs